CAN you really get the right “feel” while dancing the Lindy Hop if you always dance to non swing music (that works with the steps, like Boogie and 50´s Rock, but still)?
For some reason my instructor insists on playing music i dont even associate with the right era or attitude (Lindy was “gone” around 1945 before being resurected in the 80´s.).
He also teaches Ballroom and should be aware of the importance of character in a dance.
I LOVE Rockabilly and the 50´s but see it as another thing, an extension to Lindy.
The steps might have similarities in different Swing Dances and music might have similar syncopations or blue notes but THEY ARE different.
I should make him dance a Charleston to Ragtime to prove a point or Viennese Waltz to Scottish Jigg.
I have danced Lindy to Punk and it works (Jig Kicks) but Jazz will always go with Charleston and Swing with Lindy to me. Benny Goodman makes me think Lindy, Elvis Presley makes me think Boogie Woogie (the dance) and i´m pretty sure most would agree with me.
It MUST affect the dance to play a music unassociated to it.